Is it time for a new England captain? 🤔 After England’s shocking defeat to Afghanistan in the Champions Trophy 2025, cricket legends Michael Atherton and Nasser Hussain have openly questioned Jos Buttler’s leadership. With England now eliminated, many are wondering if a captaincy change is inevitable.
Afghanistan pulled off a stunning 325/7, powered by Ibrahim Zadran’s magnificent 177 off 146 balls. In response, England fought hard but fell short, getting bowled out for 317 in 49.5 overs. This loss shattered their semi-final hopes and put Buttler’s future as captain under scrutiny.
England Legends Demand Leadership Change
Michael Atherton, speaking on Sky Sports, did not hold back:
🗣️ “I think his time is done as captain. England judge themselves on ICC events, and this one has been a failure.”
Atherton believes that England needs a fresh leader to rebuild after a string of underwhelming performances.
Nasser Hussain, on the other hand, emphasized that Buttler shouldn’t be compared to Eoin Morgan, England’s 2019 World Cup-winning captain.
🗣️ “I’ve never looked at Buttler and thought ‘Wow, what a leader.’ He doesn’t command the field like Morgan did. Captaincy has taken away from his batting.”
What’s Next for Jos Buttler?
Despite heavy criticism, Buttler remains calm and committed, stating he will continue leading the team. However, with England now out of the tournament, all eyes are on Group A’s final battles:
🏏 Australia, South Africa, and Afghanistan are still fighting for semi-final spots.
🏏 Afghanistan must beat Australia to advance.
🏏 Australia’s win will also send South Africa through to the semis.
With the Champions Trophy campaign over, will England stick with Buttler, or is it time for a change? Drop your thoughts in the comments! ⬇️
🚨 Stay tuned to Cricket Army for the latest updates! 🚨
